Previous Post: Birth in the News   Next Post: What is Midwifery?

Protecting the fun out of childhood - Swimming Pools

When I was growing up in the early 80’s I could see 3 home swimming pools from my back yard–not a one of them were fenced.  Two of them I swam in regularly.  Now, in my development of approximately 200 houses I can count on one hand the number of swimming pools.   I blame fences for the decreasing number of pools to be found in the back yards of young families.  To be fair…there is a requirement in my development that all pools be “in ground,” which does make them too expensive for many families–but even in neighboring communities where above ground pools are not taboo, there is a scarcity of pools compared to my childhood memories. 

 

Why do I blame fences? Because even if they are installed by the homeowner, they are hardly an “easy” solution since they can be prohibitively expensive to a working class family—costing many times more than the pool itself.  Especially since many localities require fences for ANY pool, even a 12″ deep kiddie pool.  How exactly does anyone over about 18 months old drown in a 12″ pool?  I would think that even the smallest toddler is going to be able to stand up after falling into that amount of water.

 

The logic behind installing fences is that many children die from drowning, and if we could just keep the kids away from pools by using fences, we would reduce the rate of drowning.  And to be sure…drowning deaths have decreased since 1985 by approximately 30%.  Sounds impressive, huh?  Well wait until later when I talk about how many children actually die from drowning in backyard pools.

 

While I commonly see the notion tossed about that drowning in pools is the second leading cause of accidental death…I wonder where the data is to support this? In my state, drowning is actually only the 4th leading cause of injury death for children aged 1-14–following motor vehicle crashes, fires, and homicide (dropping to 5th for ages 15-24, and amounting to less than 2% of injury related deaths for all age groups). One might argue that homicides are not “accidental,” bumping up drowning to third place (many child homicides are “accidental, in that they are accidental outcomes of child abuse)…but even so, how many children are actually dying by drowning? In the 6 years from 1991-1995 less than 200 children under 20 years old died from drowning in my state–and not all of those died in swimming pools.  That means approximately 35 drownings per year, so that a decrease by as little as 12 drownings per year could result in that 30% decrease I mentioned above.  But did pool fences cause the decrease?

 

Only about half of all drowing deaths occur in pools, and quite frankly, it is difficult to parse out exactly how many do occur in pools since the data is often presented as something like “pools and water tanks.”  By my best estimate, approximately 450 children under the age of 19 die in swimming pools each year in the US.  But many of those deaths occur while the child has been allowed access to the pool by a consenting adult–so the fence is hardly protective. In fact, one study on the topic shows that as many as 45% of pool drownings in children aged 5-24 occur in PUBLIC pools–that is, pools that not only have fences, but also lifeguards in most cases!  As for backyard pools…the Consumer Product Safety Commission–in a document describing specifics for fences around pools, notes that only 2% of drownings in backyard pools* are from individuals who accessed a pool that were not residents of the home or invited guests–so if the house is inside the perimeter of the fence, it is worthless against 98% of backyard pool drownings.  One study from 1994 suggests that even 4 sided fences would be completely ineffective against 80% of pool drownings, and have questionable effectiveness against the other 20%. 

 

So only half of all drownings are in pools, and about half of those occur in public pools with fences and lifeguards.  That means that in 6 years in my state…as few as 55 children drowned in back yard pools, and only one of those would have been saved by a fence that has the house in its perimeter.   And for that…anyone who desires a pool must first install several thousand dollars worth of fencing–often about $10,000.  Even if we assume that fencing would prevent all pool drownings, it works out to an expense of over $2.2 MILLION per death prevented (($5,000 per fence * 200,000 new pools annually)/450 deaths annually).  More realistically, tens of millions of dollars are spent on fencing for each death that is prevented.

 

As a mother of two small boys, I rather FEAR fences around private pools, since I am quite confident that my boys could scale those fences, while even if I could scale them under the adrenaline of fearing for my child’s life, they would slow me down in my mission to rescue my child.  And I have more “heart stopping in fear/panic” moments in one visit at my local public pool when my routine “head count” turns up short than I have in a whole summer of my kids swimming in our backyard pool.

 

I suspect that the decline in drowning deaths that has occurred since 1985 has occurred only because of children completely loosing access to a rather enjoyable part of childhood–the home swimming pool.   Is this loss worth it, or should we be looking for a less expensive option for protecting our children?  Rigid pool covers?  Obnoxiously loud motion detector alarms?  Certainly there has got to be a solution that will allow children to enjoy summer pool fun…while protecting children from drowning.

 

Oddly enough, while regulations about installing fences around pools were all the rage by at least the early  to mid 90’s, regulations to require parents to use child safety booster seats that cost as little as $30 each took until 2004 to be passed in my state–even though motor vehicle crashes are by far the more common cause of death in children.

Don’t get me wrong…I’m all about safety since my profession for 7 years was as a Health & Safety Specialist…I just wonder sometimes if we really think about the costs of what we are doing–are we “protecting the fun out of childhood” with pool fences?   For my kids, the answer is “yes.”  Because if we were to be able to install an above ground pool in our neighborhood, the cost of installing a fence would be out of our reach.  Going to the public pool alone with 5 kids?  Probably not going to happen very often…

*It is worth noting that the CPSC gets their data about pool drownings from death certificate data, but I do not believe the death certificate categories distinguish between residential and public pools.  If this is true, the number of deaths in backyard (residential) pools is likely as low as about 250-300 incidents per year.

Tags: , , , , , , , ,

Posted in Home and Protecting the fun out of Childhood 4 years, 11 months ago at 2:21 pm.

2 comments

2 Replies

  1. [Note: With the author's permission, I'm posting this e-mail that I received here in the comments section. Jenn]

    Hi, Jenn! Thanks for the comment [on my blog]. You make some good points. I think the ” more effective method of protection” we are seeking is (drumroll please…) teaching our children how to swim! We live on the bank of Chickamauga Creek. It’s not fenced, we’ve raised several toddlers here, and none of them have ever fallen in. Of course, a steep creek bank is hardly as inviting as a rippling blue swimming pool.

    I had a look at your blog. It appears we are interested in many of the same things. I have 6 children, and the last 3 were born at
    home. I have watched my oldest daughter, who now has 2 of her own, go through the whole ridiculous pit induction to C-section nightmare, although she “knew” better. (It is very difficult for a frightened young woman in labor to overcome a whole system that is against her and threatening her with terrible outcomes, while she is in pain, etc.) I learned that C-section isn’t the worst that can happen, after the 2nd baby had serious complications from a scheduled C-section performed at 38 weeks, and ended up being denied breastmilk for several days, she couldn’t even hold him and was hardly allowed to touch him, he was kept in NICU for 2 awful weeks. It was really a nightmare, all caused by the dr’s refusal to allow her to VBAC or even wait for labor to naturally occur.

    Have you seen the birth articles on my site? I have a few, but “May, 2052″ (http://ontheotherhandcolumn.blogspot.com/2007/05/may-2052.html) is the most popular.

    Jeannie

  2. Jeannie–

    Welcome to my blog! I went and read your “May, 2052″ post, and loved it–if only it will come to pass!

    Regarding your suggestion about children learning to swim though, I think that will be of limited effectiveness. The children who most commonly drown in pools are between 12 months of age and 5 years old. There is conflicting data on whether “learn to float” drowning prevention classes for children in this age group really work. As a safety professional, I also tend to prefer “engineering solutions” rather than “human behavior solutions”–just because they tend to be more reliable.

    Which is why I think that a motion sensor of some sort–that perhaps has a key on a wrist band that must be removed to turn it off (so that a parent puts that wrist band on, and thus will be reminded to put the key back in the sensor when pool play is done), is a good solution. There are already pool motion detectors on the market for under $100, but I’m not quite sure how they work.

    Of course that still doesn’t do anything about the children who die when they are expected to be swimming–but it is a much more reasonably priced solution for the cases where the children who AREN’T expected to be swimming.


Leave a Reply


  • breastfeeding
  • and together
  • ultram interaction
  • 5 mg dose
  • foods high in vitamin k to avoid while on
  • per quanti giorni va preso
  • mass times
  • o que o pode causar
  • para que es el pomada
  • is inhaler safe during pregnancy
  • nausea treatment
  • positive results
  • cross blood brain barrier
  • acetaminophen interaction
  • overdose treatment
  • erectile dysfunction drug opera
  • pfizer lawsuit
  • panic attacks
  • dosis para 2 semanas
  • does it cause weight gain
  • motor factors dublin
  • pediatric taste
  • dosage to treat c diff
  • and uti dosage
  • vs
  • can i take and zoloft together
  • side effects stomach cramps
  • bula pfizer
  • nursing considerations
  • generic manufacturers
  • ointment pregnancy
  • how does work
  • soft tabs review
  • does 2 work
  • vs dementia
  • quintuplets
  • lek na cholesterol
  • bloating pain
  • estrogen cream
  • treatment migraine
  • difference between and
  • oglasi
  • dosage frequency
  • need help paying
  • 112 mcg cost
  • 200 efectos adversos
  • and the same thing
  • et constipation
  • pill form
  • vs
  • side effects tremor
  • peak effect
  • yellow capsule
  • 1 niAos
  • side effects tardive dyskinesia
  • can you take vicodin together
  • dose for pediatrics
  • acute renal failure
  • funny taste in mouth
  • safely
  • max dose iv
  • fda approval bipolar
  • lining
  • help sleep
  • i upotreba
  • 25 mg bula
  • epidural catheter removal
  • baby yeast infection
  • 37.5mg reviews
  • side effects of weight gain
  • does raise your blood pressure
  • medicinenet
  • liver damage
  • detox off
  • and combination
  • prescription for men
  • chemotherapy for breast cancer
  • 100mg
  • patent expiration
  • together
  • vs
  • in children
  • safe breastfeeding
  • fibromyalgia
  • cutting pills
  • diphenhydramine interaction
  • crohn's disease treatment
  • interchange
  • is over the counter drug
  • comp spc
  • 500 mg price cvs
  • new warning label
  • what are the withdrawal side effects of
  • half life
  • normal dose seizures
  • show drug screen
  • and pancreatitis
  • glaxosmithkline
  • did stock split
  • difference between retin-a and
  • tinnitus side effects
  • is 15 mg solutab otc
  • can i take with
  • side effects sleeplessness
  • normal dosage cold sores
  • drug interaction between
  • efectos secundarios largo plazo
  • and menstrual cycle changes
  • evohaler for infants
  • equivalent
  • bus tours
  • dosis pediatrica
  • autism
  • much does prescription cost
  • mamo fishman
  • ovidrel
  • 3 tagen
  • 200 mg price comparison
  • precio plus mexico
  • pulse rate
  • hordeolum treatment
  • vs lortab
  • sharp clinic san diego
  • para hombres sirve para mujeres
  • class action suit
  • sale las vegas
  • seizure medicine
  • cost costco
  • pill image
  • difference between advil and
  • for sleep side effects
  • a los 4 meses de gestacion
  • will cause hair loss
  • efectos adversos del en jovenes
  • duo early pregnancy
  • 2nd generation
  • vs migraine
  • vs
  • dose for male uti
  • absorption vitamin c
  • drug classification
  • your period
  • solution
  • induced cerebellar atrophy
  • AYurup yan etkileri
  • drug interactions
  • frequently asked questions
  • sore joints
  • side effects kidneys
  • high yahoo
  • fda approval
  • xl alcohol
  • can you get high off 60 mg
  • clonazepam
  • como tomar o em um ciclo de m-drol
  • joint stiffness
  • vs
  • what is 5 mg used for
  • how to stop taking safely
  • decreases effectiveness of
  • or for eczema
  • how many cycles to get pregnant
  • and mild rash
  • low motivation
  • qual o melhor
  • 2gm
  • can you use during pregnancy
  • is safe during early pregnancy
  • product information
  • side effects acne
  • emergency surgery
  • phentermine weight loss
  • 20mg vs 40mg
  • how much can i take in a day
  • mexico venta
  • ciclo dianabol proviron
  • lyrica drug interaction
  • equivalent
  • for a uti
  • drinking alcohol while taking
  • side effects gastrointestinal
  • can you use cream while pregnant
  • mayo clinic withdrawal
  • can i take and at the same time
  • walmart price
  • bloating gas
  • what dosage of causes hair loss
  • advil
  • is a blood thinner
  • brulures d estomac
  • ambien together
  • otic solution
  • does cause insomnia
  • 37.5 sevrage
  • oromone 2 grossesse
  • raises triglycerides
  • dea schedule
  • 3 meses
  • morning or night
  • muscle relaxer
  • y
  • kombinere paracet og
  • coupons
  • can you take and together
  • starting
  • rotator cuff injuries
  • 2nd round after miscarriage
  • tardive dyskinesia
  • burping
  • and nebuliser
  • dosage 5 days
  • can you take
  • pilula
  • settlement class
  • which is better or
  • rebate card
  • keramag waschbecken nr.1 plan
  • eljo sortiment
  • 14 day free trial
  • 20mg pfizer
  • inert ingredients
  • for glioblastoma
  • how many grams in applicator
  • during pregnancy lawsuit
  • taking while breastfeeding
  • 200 mg bula
  • can you take prozac
  • mua thuoc o dau
  • gi bleed
  • h 12
  • side effects elevated levels
  • withdrawal hypomania
  • vs etodolac
  • drugstore
  • cual es mejor o
  • side effects birth defects
  • kopen
  • and namenda together
  • does make you sleepy
  • rx coupon
  • can take while breastfeeding
  • benadryl interaction
  • and together
  • &
  • drug interactions percocet
  • abdominal cramps after taking
  • taking
  • or
  • or hair loss
  • use iud
  • classification
  • substitute
  • free samples
  • a la reunion
  • alcohol
  • hard capsules side effects
  • can take ativan
  • photos of patients
  • forest pharmaceuticals patient assistance
  • warnings
  • pediatrico def50
  • affect sperm
  • und
  • and alcohol interaction
  • side effects rash
  • can i take if pregnant
  • caffeine interactions
  • dosage
  • order
  • buy generic online overnight
  • xr gluten free
  • positieve ervaringen met
  • converting er valproic acid
  • is amazing
  • taking twice a day
  • crema gravidanza
  • and high triglycerides
  • substitute
  • drinking wine while taking
  • buy suppositories
  • dry eyes after
  • u mAodego
  • toxicity infants
  • letra y acordes incomparable
  • oder
  • side effects cramps
  • er patient assistance
  • how fast should work
  • nr. 1 halbsAule
  • dosage for strep throat
  • and high
  • how much should i take
  • chapped lips go away after
  • xr maoi
  • generic fake
  • cvs generic
  • 75 150
  • xl 100mg
  • dosage schedule
  • pill photos
  • max dose 800
  • e gravidez no primeiro ciclo
  • and levo
  • increased prostate cancer risk
  • drug interactions
  • and z pack
  • what to expect 4th month of
  • can i drink alcohol
  • cr drug interactions
  • printable coupon
  • use newborns
  • que es 10\/20
  • buy generic
  • treats what type of bacteria
  • 5mg side effects
  • is over the counter in usa
  • e ovaio micropolicistico
  • off brands
  • 175 mg
  • dose gout
  • can take nurofen plus together
  • drug abuse
  • online
  • .generic
  • o triatop
  • serve medicamento f
  • withdrawal side effects anger
  • allegra d
  • o que acontece se mulher tomar
  • super active plus 100 mg
  • d dosage weight
  • pl
  • es dawkowanie u dzieci
  • is a prescription medication
  • abraxane breast cancer
  • how much to lose weight
  • false positive
  • cystic acne
  • hair loss
  • dosing time of day
  • can you get buzz
  • farmaco a cosa serve
  • wellbutrin drug interactions
  • cream missed period
  • good for sinus infections
  • vs for strep
  • prescription vs
  • e lorazepam
  • is going generic
  • starania o ciAA?A
  • should i quit
  • website taken down
  • day 30
  • side effects withdrawal symptoms
  • d 12 hour overdose
  • price
  • interaction
  • effects jelly
  • and combination
  • accidently took 2 pills
  • home office toronto
  • effets secondaires libido
  • difference between and
  • side effect constipation
  • bayer 20 mg preis
  • and
  • pediatric overdose
  • tablet singapore
  • switch from pristiq to
  • can buy cream online
  • to increase sperm count
  • children's caplets
  • versus versus
  • 875 joint pain
  • with
  • blood test taking
  • for girls
  • commercial
  • can you take dexilant
  • long cold sores contagious after
  • cold medicine
  • buy canada
  • group bmw
  • can cause tinnitus
  • spectre d'action de
  • pregnant after 150mg
  • rx coupon
  • can cause weight gain
  • versus which is better
  • buy cheap uk
  • is safe during pregnancy
  • cost 40 mg
  • before after antibiotics
  • how take
  • and together
  • contraindications
  • eucerin cream
  • stopping before tooth extraction
  • can you take and together
  • stopping side effects